Worr's
Wingman Guide
A
lecture given by Worr
on the WarBirds BBS.
Lecture
Starts...
| Common
Mistakes in Wingman Tactics |
No
Assigned Leader
Like
Chip 'n Dale, we often go about our business of killing
Purple when we form up together. "You first". "No, no, I
insist. You first". All kindness aside, it is expedient
that one call the shots. XXXX and I have been trading off
the lead in our tactics. Leader runs out of ammo, wingman
becomes lead, and lead then becomes wingman. Lead overshoots,
wing picks up the bogie. Etc. But determine who will call
out the ACM and the bogies to chase and destroy.
If you are lead you have less work to do to preserve the
formation. Your task is offensive (though we talk about
double attack formations later). Chop throttle to 90% or
even 75% so your wingman can maintain formation. Might as
well get used to this for campaigns. Thinning out the fuel
may save your hide!
Enthusiastic wingman often try to execute their moves exactly
when their leader executes them, and follow them in tight
and precise formations. In other words, the wingman is pulling
either pure pursuit (nose on the leader) or sometimes even
lead pursuit (nose in front of the leader, anticipating
his next move. Relax, and use lag pursuit. For example,
a common mistake is when the leader pulls up into a pitch
back, the wingman immediately begins to climb. Then, lo
and behold, the wingman has turned inside the lead's pitch
back and has lost sight. Instead, extend out to the point
where the lead began his pitch back, and go even a bit further.
Then follow in his path.
[ Top of Page ]
You cannot be radio shy for wingman tactics to work. Set
up the private line, and ignore most of the other messages
once you are in the thick of battle. Beginning radio chatter
will include: load out for the mission, destination, altitude,
and formation (traditional, line abreast, loose deuce).
The wingman will also call out the distances so that proper
spacing can be maintained. (Remember that your front view
distances and his rear view distances will not match due
to net lag. Lead will need to subtract two for his rear
view).
Then the lead will call out contacts: "Con, 2 red z". Lead
will then choose bogie: "In, top z". Or, "Talley ho, trailing
38." Important also will be the response, "cc". This completes
the communication loop, and then you need not worry about
missed assignments. Major maneuvers should also be signaled.
Suggested radio abbreviations would be:
-
bp
- pitch back (or Immelmann)
-
ss
- split ess
-
br,
bl - break right, left
-
l,
r - left turn, right turn.
During combat some important radio signals would be:
-
6
- A bandit is on your six.
-
m6
- A bandit is on my six, can't shake him.
-
h
- Help.
-
easy
- Hang tough, I'm lining up the shot on that bogie
on your six.
Also calling out kills is very encouraging, and historically,
part of the confirmed kill process. Please, don't announce
your numbers over the open radio. But a private score is
fun. Especially when the other pilot calls out your kill
for you. "Wow! nice move on that Zeke!"
When it's time for an exit, you may hear this: "Bingo fuel!"
or "Bingo ammo!" which means one of the two is ready to
depart. Call out the exit sign: "Snaggelpuss, exit stage
right" Then both aircraft will hit the deck and run East.
Anything beyond this radio chatter can be ironed out between
individuals. Good humor is allowed, and encouraged.
[ Top of Page ]
Wingmen are eager for combat too. But in a real rhubarb,
any target fixation can become dangerous, especially when
both lead and wing are locked on a six of their own. Lead's
first priority will be offense; traditional wingman's priority
will be defense. (Once again, line abreast, and loose deuce
offer other advantages.) Lead can be selfless and call on
the wingman for a shot he finds to hard to pull lead for.
(n.b. Richard Bong was most generous in this fashion!) Also,
lead can be traded on alternating missions. As one ace said,
"To loose your wingman is to loose 75% of your fighting
power." Stick together, its a cruel world out there. If
you get killed, or auger, wait on the runway for your wing,
or lead, to return. Loyalty will be rewarded.
The lead, if he knows the caliber of his wingman, and trusts
his dedication, can spend less time checking six, and more
time tracking bogies than his wing man. The wingman has
a clear view of his lead's tail. A good trail distance is
10-15. Any bogie that gets in between can be dealt with.
But checking your own six is essential, and a great work
load for the wingman, than the lead. And don't just hit
the rear view from time to time, but do the twists, the
turns and the inverts, to get a good view back there at
the 6 o'clock low position. Your death will lead to your
leads death soon after. Know that you will often be the
first target on a flat out pursuit.
If the wingman gets below his lead, he will loose both his
lead and the ability to close with any bogie on his lead's
tail. A 500ft advantages would be optimum, more if your
lead can't see out the back of his FTD to eye ball you.
This potential energy (great altitude) can then be transferred
into kenetic energy (speed) to clear your lead's six in
a pinch.
[ Top of Page ]
Here
is some more information on Wingman tactics and formations.
The previous section was on common mistakes. This will look
at formations and tactics within those formations as outlined
by Robert Shaw. But first, a couple comments.
There are some things not directly portable for history
into WarBirds. It has been estimated that throughout the
history of air combat, 80 to 90 percent of downed fighter
pilots were unaware of the danger until the moment of the
attack. Surprise was the great advantage, and formations
and formation leaders, organized themselves to avoid this
situation. However, in WarBirds, there are no enema bogey
dropping out of the sun unaware, but the radar and range
indicators put a different twist on our wingman needs. Though
of course, when SA goes down, one has fallen on many occasions
to a hidden attacker. But still, at this time, formation
discipline isn't as crucial.
Also consider the lack of peripheral view in the aircraft
of WarBirds that inhibits the line abreast formation. Thought
tactically the line abreast is the better formation, it
would never work in a P-38 with not only the need to intentionally
look 90 degrees to the side, but also the fixed view limitations
of the art inhibit this. You can't move your head a few
inches to look around those bars!
Please, I beg you, revise this as needed. I am no expert
on this, but offer this as a beginning for the dialogs on
wingman tactics.
First
the formations:
Welded
Wing
This is the formation we often think of when we visualize
a two man team in flight. One is designated the lead the
other wing, and the wing man's position is anterior and
defensive. During the war this was also a mentor role for
younger more inexperienced pilots to gain combat experience
at the side of a veteran. The lead's primary tasks are navigation,
forward hemisphere search for attack planning and engaged
maneuvering and he has the secondary responsibility of rear-hemisphere
visual coverage. The Wing man flies a rather loose formation
on the leader. His primary task is maintaining a rear hemisphere
defensive look out and he has secondary forward hemisphere
duties. During WWII the separation was normally 600 ft.
My suggestion would be a range of 6 showing over your lead
and with some alt to the wingman's advantage to close on
any bogey that drops on the lead's tail. Traditional the
wing was in the right echelon position, at about 4 o clock.
Pros:
-
Releases
lead for dedicated attack
-
Requires
less discipline and training
-
A
reserve aircraft is always there to be called in when
needed
Cons:
-
Who
watches the wingman's six?
-
Only
one aircraft is engaged in dedicated attack - less pressure
on enema
-
May
frustrate the more experienced wing man to do more chasing
than killing
Double
Attack
With a double attack the wing man leader hierarchy is still
retained, however the wingman's aircraft is pressed into
offensive capabilities. Both aircraft with engage the enema
aggressively. Within this philosophy are two tradition formations:
In
brief, the line abreast formation requires the most discipline
and offers the most in tactical maneuvers that force stunning
air victories. It is the most aggressive formation, and
brings in the quickest kills, but not without risk. This
formation is for the experienced and the disciplined. Loose
deuce is more in the line of tag team wrestling. Where one
aircraft drains the E of the enema plane, using pure and
lag pursuit, and then trades off with the wing with a higher
E status.
Welded
Wing
This formation places both aircraft at 90 degrees with each
other of the 3 and 9 o'clock respectively. A great combat
spread is required, perhaps in the area of 10-12 showing
over the partner's ac. This offers several defensive and
offensive maneuvers against an approaching enema. There
is the "Offensive Split" the "Defensive Split" the "Beam
Defense" "High-Low Split" "Bracket".
What these maneuvers do, and we can cover them in a later
post, is they seek to commit the enema to pursuit of one
of the two offensive planes so that the free plane can maneuver
for the kill. As mentioned above, this requires a great
deal of discipline and much trust in the gunnery and maneuvering
proficiency of the partner pilot's abilities. Would you
offer yourself to sucker in the enema if you thought your
partner could gun him down quickly when you needed him to
do it?
Pros:
-
This
things kills them dead... it works
-
When
enema is in pursuit he becomes predictable, and thus
dead
-
It
keeps the maximum pressure on, thus leaving the initiative
with you
Cons:
-
To
apply this doctrine requires a high proficiency between
both pilots
-
It
requires discipline in terms of familiarity with maneuvers
and execution of them
-
It
suckers the enema in and the fish may swallow the bait
before you reel him in.
Loose
Deuce
This formation places both aircraft in the same position,
but a different philosophy, the that requires less discipline,
yet the same amount of team work. While in the double attack
doctrine the pilot of the engaged fighter is expected to
get the kill while the free-fighter avoids death and cheers
on, it is more often the free fighter that gets the shot
in the loose deuce. The engaged fighter sets up the kill
by forcing or inducing the bogey to maneuver predictably,
thereby making it easier for the free fighter to position
for a shot. The illustration of tag team wrestling is perhaps
helpful. The first aircraft tires the opponent draining
his precious energy, and also sets him up at the proper
position for his partner to slap his hand and merge into
the attack from above, or from an another advantageous position.
Pros:
-
It
requires less communication and discipline between pilots
-
It
is keeps the pressure on the enema, though to lesser
degree than double attack
-
It
sets up the best shot over the snap shot and thus guarantees
the kill
Cons:
-
It
makes for a prolonged engagement that in rhubarb may
not be advantageous
-
It
is vulnerable to surprise from the rear, though free
fighter often can "perch" and thus check six from there,
yet there is no coordinated defense such as in the double
attack.
Lecture
Ends...